It'd be something like this:
5. Quilava
4. Charmander
3. Ninetales
2. Typhlosion
1. Cyndaquil
Fire isn't one of my favourite types and since I'm not a Hoenn/Sinnoh person nothing from there is in the list, Unova's Fire Types were a bit.. Different so thy didn't make the list either because they didn't seem to be as majestic as Fire Types before them but since the Typhlosion line is pretty much my favourite line all round they all made theist along with the glorious Ninetales and cute little Charmander! :-)