News:

Treat dodgy posts that start arguments like unexploded WWII bombs found in your garden - don't walk upto it, and shake it around, report it to the authorities and let them deal with it. Use the report to moderator links and don't continue arguments!

Main Menu

Doctor Who

Started by Voltorb2005, March 31, 2007, 15:51

0 Members, Big Brother and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Who do you think is the best doctor who of all time?

William Hartnell
2 (2.6%)
Patrick Troughton
1 (1.3%)
Jon Pertwee
1 (1.3%)
Tom Baker
4 (5.2%)
Peter Davison
0 (0%)
Colin Baker
1 (1.3%)
Sylvester McCoy
2 (2.6%)
Paul McGann
2 (2.6%)
Christopher Eccleston
15 (19.5%)
David Tennant
32 (41.6%)
Matt Smith
17 (22.1%)

Total Members Voted: 69

Sebastian Moran

Oh my gawsh xD 
 
That was fantastic... I'm going to be all twitchy around statues from now on. I had to watch some of this with my glasses off so I couldn't see it properly.. and my mum watched it from the top of the stairs. 
Yeah, our house is mad. 
 
But that was really clever... time travelling-stuff usually makes my head hurt, and this was no exception... really good though. I love it how all the clues came together... and it all made sense [eventually]... aiiee =D 
 




be humble,
for you are
made of earth.






be noble,
for you are
made of stars.

The Librarian

I've got to admit, that was alot better that I expected. Great episode. Especialy the "Timey Wimey Detector." :P

And Cpt. Jack next week. Can hardly wait.
"SOME PEOPLE WILL DO ANYTHING FOR THE SHEER FASCINATION OF DOING IT, said Death. OR FOR FAME. OR BECAUSE THEY SHOULDN'T."

Angelic Lapras King

It was actully pretty good dispite the lack of the Doctor! The Weeping Angels were brillient villians! Bound to scare little kiddies! XD


So next week then. Jack returns and such. Looks good.




"What did I say would happen if you got onto my back Oak?"






weird one

Ohh That was great Next  week'sone looks even better.

President Hawkeye

Definately the best episode so far. It was just so cleverly set up and the storyline and the whole idea of statues was simply sublime.
I thought it was fairly easy to understand, I mean after you watch reels upon reels of the Doctor himself...
I think I like this new side and genre to the series... the horror slash psychologically tame thriller slash pure enterainment gold! I think the writers have time sussed or they shipped in a quantum theorist to help write or something.

(10/10) And don't you forget it!

LB

Good lord, that was good.

One of the best this series.

One of the best in the last three series.

Moffat's done it again!

Really good ideas, very clever, scary, exciting - and so many nods to fandom and geeks in general! Inspired.

9.5/10.

And...Captain Jack! <3
"It occurred to me that this was what you might get if Walt Disney did an animated version of a Munch painting."

"It seemed to me that the longest imaginable distance separated irregular German verb forms from this kitchen table."

FaFniR

Quote from: Lord Barnabat on June 09, 2007, 20:02
Moffat's done it again!

You took the words right out of my mouth, good sir. =]

Loved the episode. Great plot, and the method it all worked in was flawless. I really hope Steven Moffat gets the head writer position sometime soon.

"It goes "ding!" when it finds stuff."


"Footloose and fancy-free, we set off among the adventure towns, seeking the next place, rather than our fortunes."

Role Play Riffs

LOL JOHTO REMAKE

Deathmore

Utopia here we come too bad im out at 6:30 next week so i can't watch it at leat the week after would tell if mr saxon is the master

Latias Tamer

Goly! That was a good a good episode. Loved the plot and how it was solved. I love all of Steve Moffat's episodes. They always have the most mysterious plots that make the show so thrilling. Clever ideas too. The Tardis trick was great. Looks like another event the Doctor hasn't come to. Love how she gave the information, to give to him, so he could kinda translate it back... :P

I only really get a bit scared by a few Doctor Who episodes and that was one of them. The only others are the Scarecrows and the Empty Children...

Can't wait for the next episode. Looks really episode and of course Captain Jack's back. This has been a great overall series...
Yes.

Winston Payne

This episode = Great and scary.

A more complicated version of my thoughts is below.



LB

Lovely Olrik...

'They'll love this on the forums, it'll blow them completely apart!'
"It occurred to me that this was what you might get if Walt Disney did an animated version of a Munch painting."

"It seemed to me that the longest imaginable distance separated irregular German verb forms from this kitchen table."

Winston Payne

Quote from: Lord Barnabat on June 10, 2007, 09:19
Lovely Olrik...

'They'll love this on the forums, it'll blow them completely apart!'

I'm just searching for a unique style, Lord Barnabat.

But yeah, that story was very well written.


Mushroom

That was a great episode, with a really great concept (I love twisty back to front plots like this), and really great lines ("This is my timey-wimey detector, it goes bing when there's stuff").

Loved that one, Moffat is great.

Enigma

Agreed, that really was a fabulous episode.

However, about Mr. Saxon being the Master: Mr. Saxon is being played by John Simms, the dude from Life on Mars. However, the dude that looked most likely to be the master (imo) from the trailer was the old dude holding the watch or something.

I really do hope that the "other" that the Face of Boe mentioned is the Time Lord. That, or he was just making a remark about Caan's existence...>.>

FaFniR

Quote from: Enigma on June 10, 2007, 22:09
However, the dude that looked most likely to be the master (imo) from the trailer was the old dude holding the watch or something.

SPOILER


He apparently regenerates into the Master at the end of the episode. That's according to The Sun, though.


NO-MORE-SPOILAH




"Footloose and fancy-free, we set off among the adventure towns, seeking the next place, rather than our fortunes."

Role Play Riffs

LOL JOHTO REMAKE