News:

Please respect new people - everyone's new at one point!

Main Menu

Pokemon: Black & White manga

Started by Chris Riley 64, October 02, 2011, 23:55

0 Members, Big Brother and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Chris Riley 64

Is the Pokemon: Black and White manga a chapter in Pokemon Special/Adventure or is it its own manga series?

It seems shorter volumes than other, following the games more than previous chapters and there's no mention of Adventures or Special in the title.

However, the main characters are still called Black and White and the drawing style seems the same...

Anyways, what do people think about it?
Fanfic - http://pkmn.net/?action=fanfics&page=author&id=11808

Flowton

Yeah, it's part of Pokémon Adventures (look at the back of the cover, near the top). And it's AWFUL.
I suppose I've only read three volumes of it so far, but still... it's just horrible, and I don't think it can ever be fixed. The art is mostly sub-par (though I suppose that's to be expected from this series), the story - in the places where it differs from the game plot - is weird, the dialogue is depressingly bad, most of the characters are just... annoying... (especially Bianca)

My advice: Stay away. There are much better Pokémon manga series out there.

Hahex and Oshawott

Eh, I found it OK. Although I wouldn't assume my taste in manga is particlarly anything

~Evanscence~

it's rather meh to me. doesn't beat the previous Pokespe arcs though. not even close
Signature disabled. Please read the rules!

Darkwing

It doesn't seem to fit the rest of the arcs yet. White could be said to be a female Ruby but the link is weak. As for Black... Yeah I have nothing.

Hahex and Oshawott

Honestly, after reading it a little closer, I don't find the plot or characters to be particularly different from the other arcs. I don't remember liking either features at the beginning any other time, but they do eventually grow on me.
Quote from: Chris Riley 64 on October 02, 2011, 23:55
Is the Pokemon: Black and White manga a chapter in Pokemon Special/Adventure or is it its own manga series?

It seems shorter volumes than other, following the games more than previous chapters and there's no mention of Adventures or Special in the title.
I think they're published in a pokemon magazine instead of in their own volumes, which is why they might seem a bit smaller

((sorry for the necro I'll go away now))

Danse Macabre ( 6,6)

Quote from: Bluffy on November 20, 2013, 02:33
i lied i lied really hard i screwed up i'm trash i'm sorry
black is a p good character but the way they depict white and her terrible choices make me sad 8( knight/princess dynamic between the two gets old real fast

How far have you got through the series? I'm on volume 2 and haven't been amazed... but have been hoping it picks up as it goes along. Let's not forget that each volume is really short so the story doesn't have as long to grab you per purchase.
Internet celebrity in the making Danté Solablood! For all your Minecraft LP needs go to: http://www.youtube.com/user/KamenDev

Hahex and Oshawott

Quote from: Bluffy on November 20, 2013, 02:33
i lied i lied really hard i screwed up i'm trash i'm sorry
black is a p good character but the way they depict white and her terrible choices make me sad 8( knight/princess dynamic between the two gets old real fast
Yeah, wth, cant believe that whole ferris wheel thing actually happened. I've only been able to get the manga in patches so I don't really have a cohesive grasp on it yet. One day I might just buy the books :P